Why do we make people prove their pain?

| | 3 min read

Why do we make people prove their pain?

Awareness is easy. Acceptance begins with how we respond when someone says, “I'm not okay.”

If someone tells us they have a heart problem, we rarely question it. We ask what the doctor said, tell them to take care, and offer support. If someone breaks a leg, we don't ask them to think positive or expect them to carry on as if nothing has happened.

But when someone says, “I'm struggling emotionally,” the response can change. “You look fine.” “Don't overthink.” “Everyone has problems.” “Be strong.”

We have become more comfortable talking about mental health. But have we become equally comfortable with people who are struggling?

The World Health Organization estimates that nearly one in seven people globally live with a mental disorder, while stigma, discrimination and lack of access remain barriers to effective care. India's National Mental Health Survey also highlighted a substantial treatment gap. Yet the challenge begins long before someone reaches a healthcare professional. It begins at home, in classrooms, at workplaces and among friends.

A child says they are scared, and we tell them not to be. A colleague says they are exhausted, and we remind them everyone is under pressure. A friend says they are not okay, and we rush to offer solutions.

Often, we do this because we care. We want to make things better. But sometimes, our discomfort with another person's pain makes us rush to fix it rather than sit with them and listen. Advice can be useful, but not every conversation is a request for a solution.

Physical illness often comes with signs we recognise: a scan, a blood report, a fever or a fracture. Emotional distress may not be visible. Someone can attend meetings, answer messages and laugh with friends while privately struggling. The absence of visible evidence does not make the pain less real.

Perhaps we need to change the question we ask. Instead of “What is actually wrong with you?” we could ask, “What are you going through?” The first can sound like a challenge. The second makes room for a conversation.

There is a contradiction in how we approach emotional well-being. We encourage people to speak up, tell employees to prioritise well-being, and share awareness messages. But when someone actually says they need help, do we listen without judgement or quietly question their resilience?

Awareness is easier than acceptance. Posting a message is easy; changing how we respond to someone who is struggling takes patience, empathy and practice.

We don't always need the perfect words. We don't have to solve the problem or promise that everything will be fine. Sometimes, the most meaningful response is simply: “I'm listening.” Give the person space to speak. Ask what they need. If their distress is persistent or overwhelming, encourage them to seek appropriate professional support.

Breaking the taboo isn't just about making people comfortable talking about mental health. It is about making them feel safe enough to be honest, to ask for help and to say “I'm not okay” without fearing dismissal or judgement.

Perhaps the real test of our awareness is not what we post, but what we do when someone trusts us enough to share their pain.

If physical illness deserves sympathy, treatment, and time to heal, why do we still make people prove that their emotional pain is real?

Tags